Porthleven Town Council held to ransom on Public Toilets

At the August meeting of Porthleven Town Council the issue of the two Public Toilets in the Port was discussed. My view is Cornwall Council is off-loading these facilities in a rather tactless way. In simple terms Cornwall Council is saying; ‘take them over or we will close them’. It is pretty hard for a town or parish council to negotiate with both hands tied behind their backs while having to hop.

I should say in fairness to Cornwall Council, they have agreed to give a two-year grant to Porthleven Town Council to ‘help’ with the running. This is the running costs of one toilet, plus 50% of the cleaning cost. It should be noted that this is only for one toilet, as the other gets no grant.  They will hopefully refurbish the toilets to a standard that is agreeable to the town council, and not just Cornwall Council. There will be a yearly rent of £1, too.

The two options of take them over or one will close is a hard one for the town council. If the town council takes them over residents will see an increase in the town council precept to fund them, while not seeing a reduction in the overall Council Tax set by Cornwall Council. A double tax. If it does not take them over, one will shut for good.

To combat this difficult situation I have been talking to various people at Cornwall Council to try to highlight the importance of both these toilets remaining open, and pointing out it should not be the town council who has to run them. The response I got was ‘there is no money to pay for them’ or the often wheeled out  justification is ‘they are not statutory’. Car parking is not statutory, but you do not see a rush to off-load these!

I wish it was simple just to call Cornwall Council bluff and see if they will close them. However, that would not achieve anything but seeing a toilet close. That will harm Porthleven for both residents and visitors. The one earmarked for closure is the Harbour Road toilet. A Petition could be started, but again that will be most likely treated with a ‘thank you and next….’

The town council is now trying to get the best grant and refurbishment it can. Once this has been agreed in principle, the town council will be holding a mini-referendum on the proposals to the residents and business of Porthleven. That way, the town council will know it has either the backing or not. Then the town council can decide accordingly.

What should the town council to do? Take them both over or allow at least one to close?

5 comments

  • leigh yates

    I know its not ideal but could you charge for people to use the to upkeep them? I know its not a great idea but neither is losing one of them

  • They were both refurbished shortly before Cornwall Council came into being at a cost of some £7k (I think, memory’s going) so to shut one would be a shocking waste of money. The thought of somewhere as busy as Porthleven with one, somewhat hidden, public toilet is ridiculous

  • Gill Martin

    Having. Been in Porthleven all day to day I would say the toilets in Shute Lane are more important, but having said that, if beach users find that inconvenient will they return to Porthleven. Additionally, will it encourage people to use the sea as a toilet.

  • Gill Martin

    How about the companies that own holiday lets contributing financially, I find it hard to believe that if some of the holiday makers were in the town or particularly on the beach, that they would all go home to the holiday lets just to use the toilet.

  • anonymous

    What about a regular raffle/lottery for villagers? Helston Railway have a 200 Club Lottery for instance to keep money coming in. Any surplus cash could go to sorting out the playing field.

Please feel free to leave a comment to the post, as I like to hear your views! However, comments that do not meet the rules of the site (found in Blog Disclaimer) will not be published. Furthermore, all comment need to be approved by admin before publication.