Cornwall Council formally opposes the Government’s plan for Grammar Schools

Some months back, I seconded a motion to oppose the Government’s plan to expand and re-introduce Grammar Schools. At first, this motion could not be debated at Full Council because there needed to be further work carried out. That work has now been undertaken, and it is now back for a decision by the full membership of Cornwall Council.

We have a comprehensive schools system in Cornwall; it is a family of schools. When schools in Cornwall had the ability of having some form of selection when the Academies Bill became law, schools rejected it because head teachers believed in a comprehensive system.

Our education system should not be selective. Where if you do not pass an exam you are excluded from a form of education. Having an exam based entry you reinforce the notion of you are some of failure and you are not good enough if you do not pass an entrance test. Is really what we want to teach our children?

The Government’s Green Paper on Grammar Schools has so many flaws to it. For example, schools are encouraged and are working in partnership with each other to share that good practice. That will stop because there will be open competition between the Grammar Schools and the rest. The Grammar Schools trying to cream off all the top students. There are just too many flaws to the plan, it gives you the notion that this plan was not really thought through before being published.

Grammar School will not increase standards in schools. The outgoing head of Ofsted has said it will not increase standards. Even in the Govian world of education, Grammar Schools were not part of his plan; or in the mind of the previous Education Secretary, Nikki Morgan.

Every child deserves the very best education, a comprehensive system aims to do that where all abilities are catered for. I am therefore very pleased the motion for Cornwall Council to oppose the Government’s plan for Grammar Schools was massively supported by Councillors from across all parties. Only about four Councillors opposed the motion and these were not from one party either.



  • Gilly Zella Martin

    I believe extra government investment into comprehensive schools would be far better placed than into grammar schools. Surely it is better to improve the standards in comprehensive schools, not only the teaching standards but additionally in the buildings themselves, than to cause a social divisiveness between young people.

  • Isabell Austin

    As a retired teacher, I am totally opposed to grammar schools and to the ridiculous concept of “Academies “. Having worked for 32 years under the control of Cornwall County Council (and in Aberdeenshire before that), I know how important it is. County freely provided some wonderful advisers in every subject who helped and supported the classroom teachers. It appears our government is treating our education system like the NHS with the ultimate aim of privatising our precious schools.

Please feel free to leave a comment to the post, as I like to hear your views! However, comments that do not meet the rules of the site (found in Blog Disclaimer) will not be published. Furthermore, all comment need to be approved by admin before publication.